Littwin: I can’t explain why Trump won. But unlike some Trump voters, I must believe my own eyes.

I have dreaded for months writing these words. But Donald Trump has won. The MAGA restoration is complete.

And we, as Americans, must face up to what we’ve done.

Hate won. Fear won. Grievance won.

And the promise of retribution, of chaos, of even more division have won.

And it all won decisively.

Meaning democracy lost. Decisively 

For once, this is not political hyperbole. Kamala Harris stood in the way of Trump as what turned out to be a last desperate hope to stop Trump. The polls told us it was a coin flip.

If it was, heads we lose. Tails they win.

 I’m not saying this because I’m stuck in some gloom loop, although I may be. 

Want early access to
Mike’s columns?

Subscribe to get an
exclusive first look at
his columns twice a week.

SUBSCRIBE

I’m not saying it simply because the future of the Supreme Court is on the line and that Trump could get the chance to nominate so many more federal judges, taking the judiciary far to the right.

Or even because there is more than a small possibility under Trump that Project 2025 could spring mostly to life.  Or even that Elon Musk and Robert F. Kennedy Jr. — one crazier than the next — have emerged as Trump’s wingmen.

No, I say this because approximately half of Americans, give or take a few percentage points, will have voted for Trump, and I don’t know why. And I have little idea what happens next, given that so many people are so angry, so untrusting, so hung up on grievances real or imagined, so certain the other side is evil, so willing to cast aside the Constitution, that they’re ready to believe whatever outlandish lie emerges from Trump’s mouth.

For some insight, you should read Adam Serwer’s very smart piece in the Atlantic, in which he does an excellent job explaining what he calls the three rings of Trump supporters. 

The inner circle are those closest to Trump who embrace his radicalism and faux populism as a means to setting a Project 2025-like agenda. The next, and largest circle, is made up of the true believers who think the country has gone completely to hell and that only Trump can fix it. They’re the ones who see Trump as basically their cult leader. And in the third circle are Republicans who may not like much about Trump, particularly his vulgarity and casual disregard for the law, but who think tax cuts are important and immigration is out of hand and that the notion of Trump’s threat to democracy is so much liberal fearmongering.

There are two things these groups have in common. One, Serwer writes, is denial. And the other, I’d say, is grievance.

And the thing is, even though Trump won the election, none of that changes.

I can’t explain it. I’ve been trying to explain Trump’s appeal at least since he came down that golden escalator in 2015.

I can’t explain why voters seemed to embrace not only his promise of retribution against his McCarthyite version of “enemies from within,” but also that anyone he determines “cheated” in this election would face “long-term sentences” and would “be sought out, caught, and prosecuted at levels, unfortunately, never seen before in our country.”

I can’t explain why so many were unconcerned by the Trump notion that America is a hellscape that only Trump can fix. I don’t know. When I look around, I see a perfectly recognizable America. Do Americans no longer believe their own eyes?

I can’t explain why so many embraced his violent rhetoric, particularly against migrants and against women (whom he has creepily promised to “protect . . . whether the women like it or not”). But I know it has been the leading edge of Trump’s closing argument — from the lie about Haitians eating your pets to Trump’s imagery of Liz Cheney “facing nine barrels shooting at her.”

Some, including Harris, say Trump is unhinged — and if you watch his rambling speeches or saw the video of him saying that he “wouldn’t mind” if reporters get shot or heard him agreeing with his buddy RFK Jr. that it’s time to end water fluoridation, you might agree that he’s gone crazy — but I think it’s far more dangerous than that.

It looks as if Republicans will win back the Senate. The state of the House is in flux. Certainly Democrats have been rejected in this election, which could be an Electoral College landslide. And if the House goes Republican, we could see a Trump White House facing almost no restraints.

This is where we are. And now, we have to wonder where we’re going and how we can possibly turn toward something we used to call hope.

Mike Littwin has been a columnist for too many years to count. He has covered Dr. J, four presidential inaugurations, six national conventions and countless brain-numbing speeches in the New Hampshire and Iowa snow. Sign up for Mike’s newsletter.

The Colorado Sun is a nonpartisan news organization, and the opinions of columnists and editorial writers do not reflect the opinions of the newsroom. Read our ethics policy for more on The Sun’s opinion policy. Learn how to submit a column. Reach the opinion editor at opinion@coloradosun.com.

Follow Colorado Sun Opinion on Facebook.